Underdog Pick 'Em Picks For Super Bowl 60: Trust The Rhamondre Stevenson Projection

With only one game remaining, we unfortunately don't have any contests left to draft on Underdog.

Actually, that's a lie. You can draft 2026 Best Ball teams right now if you are sick enough.

What I meant, though, is that you can't draft anything Super Bowl-related.

That doesn't mean we can't have some fun. The Underdog Pick 'Em lobby is packed with all kinds of fantasy-related options that we can string together for some big prizes.

Here are some ideas if you are looking to dial up a sweat for the game …

PSA: Make sure you are taking advantage of all of the promos and boosts in the lobby. When you put together an entry, you'll see a "Rewards" section right above entering your amount. If you see one labeled "NFL", be sure to apply it before submitting your entry.

Super Bowl 60 Picks For Underdog Pick'em

The Sharp Play (Trusting The Projections)

Let's start with a more conservative approach and find the best values on the board. We can easily do this by comparing our projections to the current numbers in the Underdog lobby.

Here are three that stand out:

Rhamondre Stevenson HIGHER 50.5 rushing yards
Drake Maye LOWER 37.5 rushing yards
Kenneth Walker HIGHER 74.5 rushing yards

Our projections are showing value on all three of these numbers.

Stevenson 58.9 (+8.4)
Maye 28.6 rush yards (-8.9)
Walker 78.8 (+4.3)

The other thing I like about pairing these three together is that it tells a fairly logical story where the RBs dominate touches for their team, and Maye isn't scrambling as much because of their success on the ground. By the way, Dwain expanded on all three of these in his recent Utilization Report.

Payout: 6x. Link to tail.

The Dink & Dunk (Picking Off Small Numbers)

Sure, sweating the superstars on the biggest stage is more fun, but let's not forget about the little guys.

What I like about taking stabs at the rotational players is that they can clear their numbers in a single play. Here are three plays that I like a lot because it won't take much from them to get home:

Mack Hollins HIGHER 25.5 receiving yards
Jake Bobo HIGHER .5 reception
George Holani HIGHER 3.45 fantasy points

From Week 10 to Week 16, Hollins led the Patriots in targets while averaging 6.8. He also had a solid aDOT during that span of 15.1. Then he got injured and missed four games, but he returned in the AFC Championship game and was immediately involved with a 48% route rate. If his role climbs back to where it was pre-injury (70% route participation), he's a very strong bet to clear this number on just a couple of targets.

Bobo has caught a ball in each of the playoff games and now we are getting plus money (1.26x) on him doing it again. Yes, this is a very binary outcome, but it's a solid bet with good odds. We like the Bobo.

With Zach Charbonnet out of the lineup, the Seahawks leaned on Holani as their No. 2, and his workload was solid (3 carries and 3 targets). Considering we've previously seen him get goal-line carries, I like how many outs he has to clear this low fantasy point total (rushing, receiving, TDs).

Payout: 7.56x. Link to tail.

The Hail Mary (Sliding The Big Play WRs)

Ok, now that I have given you multiple entries with decent, if not spectacular, payouts. Let's cook up some fun longshots with bigger paydays.

Kayshon Boutte HIGHER 69.5 receiving yards
Rashid Shaheed HIGHER 34.5 longest reception

One of the fun things you can do on Underdog is "slide" the default numbers in either direction. This game provides us with two obvious big-play merchants to utilize with a slide.

In the postseason, Boutte leads the Patriots in air yards per game (86.3) and also earns a healthy target share (21%). He's shown a good connection all year with Maye, so I like the idea of sliding his receiving yards up to the higher end. Based on his profile, he can clear this number on just a few deep shots.

Shaheed has a much scarier target floor than Boutte (he's been at 2 and 3) in the playoffs, but he's always capable of hitting on a big play. Instead of needing multiple targets to clear a big number, I like the idea of just sliding his longest reception so that it's dependent on only a single play.

Payout: 25.86. Link to tail.

A Surprising Game-High Outcome (Getting Crazy)

Alright, let's go out with a bang and have some fun with the "Game High" leaders options on Underdog.

Yes, Walker and Stevenson are most likely to lead the game in rushing yards … but what if they don't?

TreVeyon Henderson has been reduced to a part-time role in the playoffs, but we know he has the ability to rip off big plays.

If the defenses step up in this matchup and limit rushing volume on both sides (a hedge against our value entry from above), then Henderson could sneak his way into the game high rushing leader on just one or two plays.

In this event, it would also be safe to assume Sam Darnold is eclipsing Maye for Game High passing yards:

Henderson GAME HIGH RUSHING YARDS
Darnold GAME HIGH PASSING YARDS

Payout: 25.89x. Link to tail.

For more ideas on Super Bowl bets, be sure to check out our Player Prop tool. Good luck.

Players Mentioned in this Article

RhamondreStevenson
RBNE
PPG
8.79
Proj
13.27
KennethWalker
RBSEA
PPG
11.19
Proj
15.49
SamDarnold
QBSEA
PPG
9.50
Proj
15.34
RashidShaheed
WRSEA
PPG
5.04
Proj
4.60